The Lost Apothecary

Bookseller recommendation

“I initially expected this book to lean more towards fantasy rather than a realistic depiction of 1700s apothecaries, but I was not disappointed. The dual timeline effectively enhances the narrative, revealing crucial information at just the right moments. The sections set in the historical apothecary are particularly captivating, with richly developed characters that stand out compared to the modern storyline. However, the ease with which Caroline uncovers information sometimes stretches believability. A bit more struggle in her discoveries would have added depth to her journey. Additionally, her reluctance to simply take a pregnancy test felt like an unnecessary plot device to maintain interest, rather than developing her character through more meaningful challenges. Despite these issues, I appreciated the character growth throughout the novel, particularly in the modern timeline, as she learns to prioritize her own happiness. Overall, the book offers an engaging storyline with compelling historical elements, making it an enjoyable read.”

— Alycia • Books on Main

Bookseller recommendation

“This book was a wonderful escape and was absolutely lovely to listen to. It switches back and forth between the point of view of two women in London in the 1790s and an American woman visiting London in present day. The story unfolds quickly. I was pleasantly surprised by the twists that I hadn't anticipated and the emotions that welled up within me. The ending was wholly satisfying and I will definitely be recommending it when it releases!”

— Lauren • Schuler Books

Bookseller recommendation

“A wonderful melding of two timelines told by a trio of female voices. Each woman is standing at a crossroads; one is just becoming a woman, one is anticipating the end of her life, and one the end of her marriage. A small, blue apothecary bottle links the women and the timelines together. Penner skillfully guides us along the path each woman chooses. I could hardly bear to put the book down, such was the need to know the choice each woman makes and the consequences of that choice.”

— Sandi Madore • Magnolia's Bookstore